January 3, 2021
/The Second Sunday after Christmas
Ephesians 1:3-6, 15-19a | Matthew 2:13-15, 19-23
The Rev. Bradley Varnell
Our Gospel lesson today skips over 3 verses that, to really get the fullest picture possible of the lesson, I think we need. Verse 16 begins: when Herod saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, he was infuriated, and he sent and killed all the children in and around Bethlehem who were two years old or under, according to the time he had learned from the wise men…This scene is what has traditionally been called the murder of the Holy Innocents. We skip over this scene because the Feast of the Holy Innocents, who might be considered the first martyrs, falls just a few days after Christmas and this portion of Scripture is read there.
The death of the Holy Innocents, of all the children under two years in Bethlehem, is the driving force for the Holy Family’s flight into Egypt. Herod’s bloodlust is fueled by the threat which this “new born King” poses to his own reign and to the rule of Rome in Israel. Herod has a cushy job and he wants to keep it, so he’ll do whatever he must to secure his position.
Over the course of Advent some parishioners and I spent time reflecting on the Four Last Things, and one of the four last things is judgement, my favorite one. We often think of judgement in punitive terms. We judge someone and make an evaluation of them, we judge someone and pass a sentence on them. Those are certainly real parts of judgement, and they’re found in Scripture, but judgement, particularly the judgement of God, has some different nuances. In Scripture judgement is about bringing the truth to light. Judgement, God’s judgement, reveals reality. Think of a courtroom, in a good, functioning, just justice system the purpose of a judgement is to declare what the truth is. That’s why you are judged then sentenced. A court passes judgement as to what the reality of a particular case might be. This is how judgement is often used of God in Scripture. And this is the judgement which Christ, by his birth, has come to bring down on us. Christ has come to judge the world, because Christ has come to show us the truth of our world.
The flight into Egypt is a moment of judgement. As the Holy Family flees to safety, as the innocents of Bethlehem are slaughtered, the judgement of God is revealed against Herod because we see the truth of Herod’s rule, of Rome’s rule. The flight into the Egypt shows the very nature of Herod’s cushy job, the cost the good order of kingdom requires.
What the judgement reveals, however, is complex. We look at Herod and see in him one of the bad guys of the Gospels. But if we step back and think for a moment, we see that he was a man who had a job to do, he was a ruler, the king, his job was to protect Israel, his people, the Romans who he served, from threats to their interest. He had laws to uphold. Kings cannot, as a matter of course, simply allow would-be usurpers to just…wander about. Herod was made aware of a threat and took care of it. Sure, the threat was a newborn, but he was a threat nonetheless. The judgement of God reveals not simply that great evil exists, but that so often, great evil exists and is perpetrated under the guise of “doing one’s job” of “doing one’s duty.” The judgement of God reveals how evil is often not something we add on top of our lives and work, but is something imbedded within it.
This story not only judges Herod, but every government, every. There has been no nation on earth, no power, no empire that has not, in some way secured itself by the blood of innocents. How many enslaved Africans had to die for us to build America? How many Native Americans had to die to make room for our manifest destiny? How many women, men, and children were sacrificed in the engine of progress as the lives of the comfortable were made even cushier?
As Christians, we are called to be a people who open our eyes to the violence of the world, who do not shrink back when the innocents are killed. And there are too many instances of innocent slaughter to name everyone. But there are two that hit close to home for me, and that I think a fitting to mention on this day in which we remember the Holy Family’s flight. First, is the Syrian refugee crisis, entering its 11th year, in which millions have been displaced around the world. Second, is immigration at the southern border, where many fleeing violence and instability in central America – including many children – have sought some form of sanctuary in the US. These people fleeing violence are no different than the Holy Family. They bear witness to the judgement of God, to the truth which God in Christ continues to reveal. When we see these people as “problems,” as “blights” as “threats” we close our eyes to the truth. But in his coming among us, Christ has invited us to open our eyes to the light, to see the truth, and boldly face it, knowing that it is only in finding the truth, and living into the truth that we will be free.
Christ came into the world at Christmas as king, savior. This has dramatic, far-reaching implications for us. If we are to be Christians, to be citizens of heaven, subjects of Christ, then all other allegiances must be relativized. Christ has come into the world and shown us the nature of our governments, he has revealed to us the way in which human systems depend on violence to secure themselves. We live in that violent world. We live as beneficiaries of the violence that has made our country and our world what it is, we live as beneficiaries of the violence that even now happens to make our lives possible. Christ has called us to see that violence. To stand against it. To speak out for the innocents. Christ has given us a new way, a different way, to be in the world. To be citizens of a kingdom not maintained by the violent securing of power but maintained by the self-giving love of God for all God’s creatures.
Amen.